FORMATION OF ANTIQUE RHETORIC: CHRONOLOGY OF RHETORICAL METHODS AND STYLES (PLATO, ARISTOTLE)
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.15802/ampr2013/14569Keywords:
rhetoric, speech theory, true/false eloquence, sophism, scientific discipline, speech, styleAbstract
Purpose of the article: to analyze the basic points of philosophical concepts of rhetoric of Plato and Aristotle, to prove that from Plato the rhetoric in the true sense starts being approved, and Aristotle is an ancestor of real theory of speech of the new genre, the new form, the new purposes and tasks of the description of verbal art. Problem statement: development of the ancient principles of rhetorical style’s creating is reached by efforts of outstanding speakers, each of them were differed not only by the ideological sympathies or antipathies, but also by nature of works, the concepts put in their basis. Two Ancient Greek philosophers: Plato and Aristotle are considered as founders of ancient rhetorical science. Methodology. Author has used system method, methods of content and comparative analysis. Scientific novelty is displayed in the received results from the comparative analysis of two concepts of public speech of Plato and Aristotle from a position of philosophical justification of rhetoric’s rules with orientation on ancient "popular" declamation practices. Practical value of article consists in development of insufficiently studied object "Antique declamation discourse" where Plato and Aristotle's two central rhetorical concepts appear as the intermediate stage in development of a declamation discourse of Ancient Greece and, subsequently, and Ancient Rome. Conclusions. The conclusions can be given by the following facts: from Plato the rhetoric in the true sense is approved: true rhetorical art isn’t based only on argument technique, the true rhethor appears as the philosopher. Plato raises the problem of an ambiguity of two opposite rhetorics presented in "Gorgias" and "Phaedrus ". Rhetoric as scientific discipline, as the present theory of speech is first considered by Aristotle. The rhetoric is presented as the science "about speech and about thoughts", about the relation of thinking to the word.
References
Antichnaya poetika. Ritoricheskaya teoria i praktika [Ancient poetic: Rhetoric science and literature practice]. M., Nauka, 1991. 254 p.
Aristotel. O sofisticheskikh oprovergeniakh [On Sophistical Refutations]. M., Mysl’, 1978, V. 2. Pp. 533-593.
Aristotel. Poetika. Ritorika [Poetics. Rhetoric]. SP: Izdatel’skiy Dom «Azbuka-klassika», 2008. 352 p.
Aristotel i antichnaya literature [Aristotle and ancient literature]. Moskva: Izdatel’stvo “Nauka”, 1978. 231 p.
Gasparov M.L. Ob antichnoy poezii: Poety. Poetika. Ritorika [About ancient poetry: Poets. Poetics. Rhetoric]. SP.: Azbuka, 2000. 477 p.
Gasparov M.L. Tsiseron I antichnaya ritorika [Cicero and ancient rhetoric]. M, Nauch.-izd. tsentr, 1994. Pp. 7-73.
Kassen B. Effekt sofistiki [L'effet sophistique]. M.-SP.: Moskovskiy filosofskiy fond, Universitetskaya kniga, Kulturnaya initsiativa, 2000. 238 p.
Kuznetsova T.I., Strel’nikova I.P. Oratorskoye iskusstvo v Drevnem Rime [Oratory art in ancient Rome]. M.: Izd ‘Nauka”, 1976. 288 p.
Pevnitskiy V.F. Tserkovnoye krasnorechie I ego osnovnyye zakony [Church eloquence and its basic laws]. Sp.: I. L. Tuzov, 1908. 304 p.
Platon. Gorgiy [Gorgias]. M.: Eskimo, 2008, V. 1. pp. 255-366, Antologia mysli
Platon. Fedr [Phaedrus]. M.: Eskimo, 2008, V. 2. pp. 777-842, Antologia mysli
Folkman R. Retorika grekov I rimlyan [Rhetoric of the Greeks and Romans]. Revel’: Pechatnaya g.Matizena, 1891. 42 p.
Aristoteles. Rhetorica Et Poetica. BiblioLife, 2010. 216 σ.
Fuhrmann Manfred. Die antike Rhetorik: eine Einführung. Patmos Verlag GmbH + Co.K, 2007. 160 S.
Andrew R. Cline. Rhetorica: A Rhetoric Primer: Plato — Isocrates — Aristotle. Missouri: Missouri State University, 2005. 206 p.
McCoy Marina. Plato on the Rhetoric of Philosophers and Sophists. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2007. 220 p.
Poulakos John. Sophistical Rhetoric in Classical Greece. Publisher: University of South Carolina Press, 2008. 240 p. (Studies in Rhetoric/Communication).
Walton Douglas. Media Argumentation: Dialectic, Persuasion, and Rhetoric. Cambridge: Cambridge University press, 2007. 400 p.
Williams James. Introduction to Classical Rhetoric. 2009. 448 p.
СПИСОК ВИКОРИСТАНИХ ДЖЕРЕЛ / СПИСОК ИСПОЛЬЗОВАННЫХ ИСТОЧНИКОВ
(ДСТУ ГОСТ 7.1:2006)
Античная поэтика: Риторическая теория и литературная практика: сборник / отв. ред. М. Л. Гаспаров. – М. : Наука, 1991. – 254 с.
Аристотель. О софистических опровержениях / Аристотель; [пер. с древнегреч.; ред. З. Н. Микеладзе] // Сочинения: [в 4 т.]. – М. : Мысль, 1978. – Т. 2. – С. 533–593.
Аристотель. Поэтика. Риторика / Аристотель; [пер. с др.-греч. В. Аппельрота, Н. Платоновой]. – СПб. : Издательский Дом «Азбука-классика», 2008. – 352 с.
Аристотель и античная литература. – М. : Издательство «Наука», 1978. – 231 с.
Гаспаров, М. Л. Об античной поэзии: Поэты. Поэтика. Риторика / М. Л. Гаспаров. – СПб. : Азбука, 2000. – 477 с.
Гаспаров, М. Л. Цицерон и античная риторика / М. Л. Гаспаров // Цицерон Марк Туллий. Три трактата об ораторском искусстве. – М. : Науч.-изд. центр "Ладомир", 1994. – С. 7–73.
Кассен, Б. Эффект софистики / Б. Кассен; [пер. с фр. А. Россиуса]. – М. – СПб. : Московский философ. фонд, Университетская книга, Культурная инициатива, 2000. – 238 с.
Кузнецова, Т. И. Ораторское искусство в Древнем Риме / Т. И. Кузнецова, И. П. Стрельникова. – М. : Изд-во «Наука», 1976. — 288 с.
Певницкий, В. Ф. Церковное красноречие и его основные законы / В. Ф. Певницкий. – СПб. : И. Л. Тузов, 1908. – 304 с.
Платон. Горгий / Платон; [пер. с древнегреч. М. С. Соловьева, Я. М. Борковского, А. В. Болдырева и др // Диалоги. Кн. 1. – М. : Эксмо, 2008. – Т. 1. – С. 255–366. – (Антология мысли).
Платон. Федр / Платон; [пер. с древнегреч. М. С. Соловьева, Я. М. Борковского, А. В. Болдырева и др. // Диалоги. Кн. 1. – М. : Эксмо, 2008. – Т. 2. – С. 777–842. – (Антология мысли).
Фолькман, Р. Реторика греков и римлян / Р. Фолькман. – Ревель : Печатня г. Матизена, 1891. – 42 с.
Aristoteles. Rhetorica Et Poetica. BiblioLife, 2010. – 216 σ.
Fuhrmann, Manfred. Die antike Rhetorik: eine Ein-führung. Patmos Verlag GmbH + Co.K, 2007. – 160 s.
Andrew, R. Cline. Rhetorica: A Rhetoric Primer: Plato – Isocrates – Aristotle. Missouri: Missouri State University, 2005. – 206 p.
McCoy, Marina. Plato on the Rhetoric of Philosophers and Sophists. – Cambridge : Cambridge University Press, 2007. – 220 p.
Poulakos, John. Sophistical Rhetoric in Classical Greece. – Publisher: University of South Carolina Press, 2008. – 240 p. (Studies in Rhetoric/Communication).
Walton, Douglas. Media Argumentation: Dialectic, Persuasion, and Rhetoric. – Cambridge : Cambridge University press, 2007. – 400 p.
Williams, James. Introduction to Classical Rhetoric. – 2009. – 448 p.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2013 Anthropological Measurements of Philosophical Research
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
- Authors retain copyright and grant the journal right of first publication with the work simultaneously licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution License that allows others to share the work with an acknowledgement of the work's authorship and initial publication in this journal.
- Authors are able to enter into separate, additional contractual arrangements for the non-exclusive distribution of the journal's published version of the work (e.g., post it to an institutional repository or publish it in a book), with an acknowledgement of its initial publication in this journal.
- Authors are permitted and encouraged to post their work online (e.g., in institutional repositories or on their website) prior to and during the submission process, as it can lead to productive exchanges, as well as earlier and greater citation of published work (See The Effect of Open Access).
